James' Flavor Guide

Twist wrapped ends are called "tails"
*=Nautral

Salt Water Taffy
*Banana - yellow with orange tails
*Cherry - pink with red tails
*Chocolate - brown with brown tails
*Cinnamon - white with yellow tails
Coconut - white with brown tails
Grape - purple with green tails
*Lemon - yellow with yellow tails
Lime - green with green tails
Licorice - black with red tails
*Molasses - tan with yellow tails
*Molasses Mint - tan with orange tails
*Orange - orange with orange tails
*Peppermint - white with red tails
*Strawberry - pink with pink tails
*Vanilla - white with blue tails
Wintergreen - white with green tails
Sugar-Free Salt Water Taffy
Banana - yellow
Chocolate - brown
Lime - lime green
Organe - orange
Peppermint - blue
Raspberry - pink
Vanilla - white
Chocolate-Sealed Salt Water Taffy
Banana - gold foil
Cherry - cherry and leaf foil
Chocolate - red foil
Coconut - dark blue foil
Orange - orange foil
Peanut - pink foil
Peppermint - dark green foil
Raspberry - purple foil
Vanilla - light blue foil
Fabulous Salt Water Taffy Flavors
The Tiki Bar:
Bay Breeze - half pink, half yellow
Pina Colada - half white, half yellow

From the Fruit Bowl:
Blueberry - blue with dark blue stripes
Watermelom - green with pink center
Passion Fruit Orange - half orange, half yellow

Forbidden Desserts:
Cookies 'n' Cream - brown with white stripes
Peanut Butter Cup - chocolate with peanut butter center
Cookie Dough - light brown with brown stripe

Snack Time:
Peanut Butter & Jelly - tan with peanut butter and jelly center
Candy Apple - half pink, half white

Pucker Them Lips:
Sour Apple - apple green
Sour Grape - purple
Sour Cherry - pinkish red
Filled Center Salt Water Taffy
Chocolate - with fudge center
Vanilla - with fudge center
Lime - with jelly center
Lemon - with jelly center
Banana - with nut center
Molasses - with nut center
Strawberry - with coconut center
Orange - with coconut center
Rum & Butter Toffee
Rum Toffee - red wax paper
Butter Toffee - yellow wax paper

 

Fralinger's Flavor Guide

Salt Water Taffy
Banana - yellow with brown stripe
Chocolate - chocolate brown
Lemon - lemon yellow
Lime - lime green
Licorice - gray
Molasses - tan
Molasses Mint - tan with brown stripe
Orange - orange
Peach - peach with red stripe
Peanut Butter - white with a peanut center
Peppermint - white with blue stripes
Root Beer - white with brown stripes
Spearmint - white with green stripes
Strawberry - strawberry pink
Teaberry - white with red stripes
Vanilla - white
Sugar-Free Salt Water Taffy
Banana - yellow
Chocolate - brown
Lime - lime green
Organe - orange
Peppermint - blue
Raspberry - pink
Vanilla - white
Chocolate-Sealed Salt Water Taffy
Banana - gold foil
Cherry - cherry and leaf foil
Chocolate - red foil
Coconut - dark blue foil
Orange - orange foil
Peanut - pink foil
Peppermint - dark green foil
Raspberry - purple foil
Vanilla - light blue foil
Fabulous Salt Water Taffy Flavors
The Tiki Bar:
Bay Breeze - half pink, half yellow
Pina Colada - half white, half yellow

From the Fruit Bowl:
Blueberry - blue with dark blue stripes
Watermelom - green with pink center
Passion Fruit Orange - half orange, half yellow

Forbidden Desserts:
Cookies 'n' Cream - brown with white stripes
Peanut Butter Cup - chocolate with peanut butter center
Cookie Dough - light brown with brown stripe

Snack Time:
Peanut Butter & Jelly - tan with peanut butter and jelly center
Candy Apple - half pink, half white

Pucker Them Lips:
Sour Apple - apple green
Sour Grape - purple
Sour Cherry - pinkish red
Filled Center Salt Water Taffy
Chocolate - with fudge center
Vanilla - with fudge center
Lime - with jelly center
Lemon - with jelly center
Banana - with nut center
Molasses - with nut center
Strawberry - with coconut center
Orange - with coconut center
Rum & Butter Toffee
Rum Toffee - red wax paper
Butter Toffee - yellow wax paper